All posts in the Sherlock category

Sherlock: His 9 Most Brilliant Deductions

Published December 11, 2013 by gossipzoo

Sherlock On Screen Modern

Sherlock is possibly one of the most genius shows that the BBC has ever produced and that makes Sherlock himself one of the biggest geniuses on TV. Whilst Benedict Cumberbatch’s portrayal of Sherlock is interesting on many levels it is his many deductions, both arbitrary and important, that make the character and show what it is.

Choosing his best ever deductions, feels like choosing Real Madrid’s best players. They’re all brilliant and sifting out the best ones is a near impossible task. Nevertheless, despite my better judgement, I have given it a go.

Ranking them in order was too big a task so here, in chronological order are the nine best deductions of Sherlock Holmes.

9. Initial Analysis Of Watson

Martin Freeman Sherlock

This deduction is absolutely essential to this list. This is the first time that we meet Sherlock and get to see his brain in action. He stuns his potential housemate, John Watson, into silence by asking him whether he has served in Afghanistan or Iraq. He goes on to describe intimate details of John’s life. These include his strained relationship with his estranged brother, the breakdown of his brother’s marriage because of his alcoholism and the fact that his limp is psychosomatic.

The ways in which he deduces these things is, in typical Sherlock style, brilliant in the simplicity of it. John has tan line on his hands with no tan below the wrist. This tells Sherlock that he has recently been abroad but working not on holiday. His stance as he entered the room and his mannerisms tell Sherlock that he is a military man and this leads to ‘Afghanistan or Iraq’, for example.

Of course, Sherlock does make one mistake. John’s ‘brother’ is actually John’s lesbian sister. She is an alcoholic, however, and her relationship did break down. The mistake only serves to make Sherlock seem vaguely human and this scene is one of the most striking character introductions in TV.

The post Sherlock: His 9 Most Brilliant Deductions appeared first on WhatCulture!.

%d bloggers like this: